Car Insurance After a DUI in New York: What It Actually Costs
New York skips the SR-22 system entirely. That doesn't mean a DUI is cheap here — but the filing process and the rate impact both work differently than in most states.
New York doesn't use SR-22
Most states require an SR-22 filing after a DUI. New York is one of the exceptions: instead, your insurer files Form FS-20 with the DMV, which simply confirms you maintain New York's standard minimum liability coverage — the same 25/50/10 plus PIP requirement described in our New York minimum coverage guide. There's no separate certificate type or elevated coverage requirement the way Florida's FR-44 demands; New York just requires proof that ordinary minimum coverage stays continuously in force.
What a DUI does to your New York premium
| Scenario | Typical monthly cost |
|---|---|
| Clean record | ~$118 |
| With a DUI on record | ~$177 |
| Increase | ~50% (~$708/yr) |
How the surcharge eases over time
The DUI surcharge doesn't stay flat for the full 3-year window most New York insurers apply — it's worst right when the conviction is fresh and eases in stages as your record ages, assuming no new violations:
| Point in time | What typically happens |
|---|---|
| Year 1 | Highest rates, fewest carriers willing to quote at all |
| Years 2-3 | More carriers compete for the business; annual decreases of roughly 10%-25% |
| Right after most insurers' surcharge window ends | Some insurers cut the rate a further 10%-15% at that renewal, and some drivers see drops of 30%-50% in the year immediately following |
| Around the 5-year mark | Most insurers treat the driver close to normally again, assuming a clean record since the DUI — even though the conviction itself stays on the New York record for 15 years |
Which insurers tend to be cheapest after a DUI
Published rate surveys for a full-coverage policy after one DUI consistently rank a handful of carriers well below the national average — and since New York doesn't force drivers into a separate high-risk filing category, more of these standard carriers remain an option here than in strict SR-22/FR-44 states. One also posts a specifically New York rate worth calling out:
| Insurer | Typical rate | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Progressive | 28% below NY state average | Cited as the cheapest option specifically in New York DUI comparisons |
| State Farm | ~$192/mo (national) | -43% vs. national average |
| Travelers | ~$236/mo (national) | -30% vs. national average |
| National General | ~$249/mo (national) | -26%; actively accepts DUI applicants |
| GEICO | ~$334/mo (national) | Baseline in this national comparison |
| USAA | ~$150/mo (national) | Cheapest nationally, but restricted to military members, veterans, and their families |
What affects the size of the increase
Insurer
Because New York's system doesn't force drivers into a separate high-risk filing category the way SR-22/FR-44 states do, more standard insurers remain willing to keep DUI drivers on a regular policy — but pricing still varies significantly between carriers.
Region
As with New York's baseline rates generally, a DUI surcharge on top of an already-higher NYC-area premium produces a bigger dollar increase than the same surcharge applied to a lower upstate base rate.
Prior record
A single first-offense DUI with no accident involved increases rates less than a DUI combined with an at-fault crash or additional violations.
Ways to lower the cost
- Shop multiple insurers — since New York doesn't force a separate high-risk filing category, more carriers compete for this business than in strict SR-22/FR-44 states, which can work in your favor if you compare.
- Keep coverage continuous throughout the FS-20 filing period.
- Ask directly how long your specific insurer surcharges for a DUI, since the 3-year figure is a general average, not a guarantee.
- Re-shop once you're past the typical 3-year surcharge window, even though the conviction remains on your record for 15 years.
Frequently asked questions
Does New York require SR-22 insurance after a DUI?
No — New York uses Form FS-20 instead, which confirms the driver maintains the state's standard minimum liability coverage.
How much does a DUI raise car insurance rates in New York?
Published data shows roughly a 50% increase, around $708 more per year for a typical driver.
How long does a DUI affect car insurance rates in New York?
The conviction stays on record 15 years, but most insurers stop surcharging the policy after about 3 years.
See our related guides for New York: teen drivers and senior drivers. Curious how New York's Form FS-20 compares nationally? See our SR-22 requirements by state reference.
Sources
- MoneyGeek, "DUI Car Insurance in New York: Cost and Cheap Rates (2026)" — accessed September 2026
- SR22direct, "New York SR-22 Insurance" — accessed September 2026
- FindLaw, "Auto Insurance Rates and SR-22 Forms After a DUI" — accessed September 2026
- Ocho, "SR22 Insurance Cost: What You'll Actually Pay in 2026" — accessed September 2026
- InsureMojo, "Car Insurance After a DUI: Costs and Best Companies 2026" — accessed September 2026
- Insurance.com, "New York DWI insurance: How much does a DWI raise your insurance?" — accessed September 2026
See our methodology and disclaimer — these are estimates, not a quote, and this page is not legal advice.